Essential Question: How is everything connected from the perspectives of indigenous peoples and Western scientists? What are the advantages to knowing both ways?
Explain:
From an indigenous perspective, everything in natural is circular, holistic, and has a practical application. Sila, or spirit, is in all things and connects human life, time, and everything in the world. This approach comes from surviving and living at an intimate level with nature and is not something that can be learned solely from a textbook. Oral history is essential to this approach as each generation learns from the past.
The Western perspective is more explanation-based, mathematical and begins with a focus on parts, rather than a whole. The Western perspective can also look at the whole, however, by connecting the ideas and research from many different scientific disciplines. Physics, biology, oceanography, and many other specific areas of study can be meshed together to provide a study of our universe as a whole, and not just separate parts.
There is an overlap between both perspectives. The common ground between the two recognizes that empirical observation, verification, and objectivity can mesh with the close ties to the land and practical knowledge that Native perspectives bring to the table.
Extend:
Although I do not teach science, I do not think it would be impossible to mesh both indigenous knowledge and the tenets of Western science within the same curriculum. Teachers try everyday to make relevant connections between “book” learning and everyday life. Even non-indigenous teachers could create lessons that incorporate Native ways of knowing; for example, a unit on climate change could focus on a particular rural community in Alaska. Students could interview Native elders on what their view of climate change is and how it might change their lives, and then they could look at quantitative data on how that change is happening. I really feel that both perspectives could complement each other. I think we can get more Alaska Native students involved in science if we could apply what they are learning in class to what they have experienced on a practical level.
As a social studies teacher, I do not often incorporate science into my lessons, but it is important for me to include indigenous perspectives. When doing my World War II unit, I include the Native perspective of the Aleuts being forcefully moved from the Aleutians into internment camps. I think is vital that we not only see the past or present solely from the perspective of the “dominant” culture.
Evaluate:
What is the value of knowing both ways? Knowing both ways provides a win-win situation. As the Alaska Native Science Commission pointed out, having a partnership between Native communities and Western researchers who are supporting them with needed data is an essential plan. Climate change is a very real concern for many of our rural communities who are seeing the change firsthand. As the Indigenous Peoples’ Global Summit on Climate Change (April 20-24, 2009) has stated, indigenous peoples are “on the front lines of climate change.” Traditional ways of survival must accommodate the changes in climate and it would benefit these communities to have as much research as possible to help them adapt.