Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Module IX Response

Essential Question:
How are climate, terrestrial ice and Alaska indigenous cultures all connected?



Explain:
To answer this question, I think a brief look at Point Hope would be appropriate. Point Hope is a community in Alaska that is being affected by permafrost melt. Underground cellars called “sigluaq” have provided safe food storage for centuries for the Inupiat peoples. While modern refrigerators could be used, Point Hope residents still use the cellars because they are convenient and economical. Temperatures have increased significantly in the past years and the permafrost can no longer be relied on to keep the cellars cold.




The most significant problem that permafrost melt has caused is that food is now spoiling in these cellars and the residents of Point Hope are at risk for food-based illnesses. The Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium points out that Salmonella, E. coli, and Norovirus are just a few of the pathogens that can cause severe illness.  This is especially a concern for the elderly, pregnant, and infants. Whale meat needs to be stored at even colder temperatures than regular food, so the cellar storage should be at -10 degrees for optimal and safe storage. During the summer months, melting permafrost is also causing water to invade the storage units. Food storage is not the only problem for Point Hope residents; the village's airstrip is also vulnerable and foundations are settling in subsistence camps. 

The Consortium suggests improving the current environment through drainage and ventilation as one method to combat permafrost melt. Another suggestion is to establish cellars in different locations that are not as affected by the melting. Alternative methods of food storage are also being considered, although this is a big impact on a cultural way of life that has been using natural cellars for thousands of years. 

Clearly, Point Hope provides an example of the relationship between land ice, climate and indigenous culture. Click here for a cool PDF of permafrost locations in the Point Hope area.


Extend:
How do the Point Hope Inupiat interpret climate change? There is plenty of Western Scientific data about the role of climate change in this region of Alaska, but how does an indigenous culture represent such change in their oral traditions? Chie Sakakibara interviewed the Inupiat and found that they have a lot of uncertainty about the future. Since the Point Hope residents have already had to move once due to climate changes, they have a very transient outlook on the future, but still have strong cultural ties to the past. One constant theme in their stories is "spirit-beings," or ghosts. Before the 1976 move from the Old Town, the spirits were said to inhabit the tundra. After 1976 when the Old Town was abandoned, the stories changed to the ghosts inhabiting the Old Town. Currently, the ghosts in Inupiat stories are transient; interestingly, this seems to coincide with the extreme uncertainty of where the Iniupiat might live in the future. 

The bond between the people and the land is still strong in their storytelling, and storytelling actually helps the people retain communication with the land, even as that land changes under their feet. Here is a short clip of the Point Hope mayor taking a tour through a sod house in the Old Town which is no longer used because of climate change.

Evaluate:
I found this lesson to be enjoyable. I think this lesson ties in well with history; changes in land ice can have an impact on historical sites, artifacts, and oral histories. I have been interested in glaciers and permafrost since I can remember and it was great to learn more about the science behind them. I'll leave you with some photos of a trip to Child's Glacier outside of Cordova. This is the best glacier I have visited in Alaska, and the coolest campground where you can listen to the glacier calving all night long into the Copper River.