Saturday, March 13, 2010

Module VII Response

Essential Question:
How is earth’s climate connected to its geological, biological, and cultural systems?

Explain:
A Gallup poll done a few days ago shows that Americans are becoming increasingly skeptical about global warming and its causes. Is the earth’s climate actually connected to its geological and biological systems? According to the poll, 50% of Americans feel that human causes are causing global warming, and 46% feel that it is due to natural causes.
http://www.ktva.com/oldlocal/ci_14657479?source=rss

“Climategate” in the recent months has only fueled this skepticism. Many people are increasingly wary of the scientific world as they feel data is being manipulated to support global warming. Instead of looking to see if these claims are substantiated, many people I have met feel that global warming is no longer a valid or real problem.
http://factcheck.org/2009/12/climategate/

I cannot describe how many comments have shown up on my Facebook news feed this past winter decrying global warming. After every snowstorm or short-term freeze on the East Coast, multiple sarcastic comments would appear stating that global warming is a myth. The following graph would suggest that we are certainly experiencing global warming, regardless of public opinion.



The connection between the earth’s climate and cultural systems is very apparent in Alaska. Global warming has actually provided a forum where both Western and indigenous knowledge can agree: change is happening, and we need to figure out the causes so the Native way of life can continue. Impacts include thinning sea ice, severe storms, and flooding; Native elders have been noticing these changes long before global warming became a topic on contention in the media.
http://www.nativescience.org/assets/Documents/PDF%20Documents/Impact%20of%20Climate%20Change%20on%20Alaska%20Native%20Communities.pdf

Climate change is something that we cannot, and will not, ignore. Even former Senator Ted Stevens, who is not the voice of “liberal” America, has conceded that climate change is indeed happening in Alaska and is having a deep impact on Native villages. Although he is skeptical that the change is man-made, it demonstrates that there is an undeniable connection between climate, geology, biology, and culture.
http://onthehillblog.blogspot.com/2007/02/sen-stevens-sees-climate-change.html

Extend:
I liked the prompt in this week’s lesson about creation stories. As a person who is at best an agnostic, but raised in a Christian faith, it has always fascinated me to see how different cultures see their origins. Some include a creator figure, some do not, and most all have a strong nature element. I particularly like the Korean story which states that the Heavenly King established three ministers on earth to be in charge: Earl Wind, Chancellor Rain, and Chancellor Cloud. These stories are not only interesting from an anthropological level, but also from a scientific perspective. Climate is a recurring theme in all of these stories.
http://www.indigenouspeople.net/legend.htm

Evaluate:
This lesson was very interesting to me because it provides such a different perspective than the one that I was exposed to as a child. Being raised in a religion that dates the earth as no more than 6,000 years old, and being homeschooled with religious texts K-12, I missed being exposed to the Western scientific perspective that is common knowledge for most. There is such a huge gap between strict religious beliefs about the origins of earth/man and what the majority of the scientific world believes. It is endlessly interesting to me to investigate the connections/disconnections between both “theories” and see how those beliefs display themselves in cultural practices around the world.

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Module VI Response

Essential Question:

How are the Earth, atmosphere and cultures all connected?

Explain:
As the videos and interactive links in this week’s lesson described, the atmosphere and ocean both have an effect on what happens on earth and what happens to different cultures. I especially liked the fifth section of the module which highlighted how contaminants are infiltrating the Arctic region. I was not aware that this was such a problem and was equally not aware that most of these contaminants are coming from Europe, Russia, and the continental U.S. Taking a glance at the Alaska Native Science Commission’s website, they are clearly aware of this problem. They state that “The Arctic is a focus for major atmospheric, riverine, and marine pathways which result in the long-range transport of contaminants into and within the Arctic. The Arctic is, therefore, a potential contaminant storage reservoir and/or sink.” http://www.nativescience.org/html/contaminants.html

Radiation as a by-product of nuclear testing has been especially concerning as it has been seen in the lichen that the caribou forage on for sustenance. Other changes that have been noted include seal skins becoming thinner, yellowish (rather than clear) seal oil, tumor/sores/lumps found on birds, fish, and land mammals, and sharks being spotted further up north. As ANSC points out, the only way to resolve these issues is to link Native knowledge to Western knowledge. The advantage of the Native perspective is that they are used to looking for patterns, migration changes, and can see pollution at a visceral level. A Western scientist is probably not going to notice changes in animal skins while sewing; a Native would notice these signs immediately.

It is undeniable that the Arctic has become polluted from many different causes. The challenge is to mitigate these negative changes by merging traditional knowledge with Western knowledge.

Extend:
I liked this diagram of how polutants travel to the Arctic region:


The Norwegian Polar Institute has a basic overview of pollutants in the Arctic:
http://npweb.npolar.no/english/subjects/Miljogifter

I was also curious about the prompt to research nursing mothers in the Arctic. I was not aware of any problems, but it appears that the consumption of blubber and other animals that have high amounts of organic pollutants can cause high levels of toxins in the fetus or infant.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/story/2003/06/25/blubber030623.html

The Canadian Arctic Contaminants Assessment Report says that “Recent research associates dioxin, furan, and PCB levels in human milk with subtle clinical, immunological, and neurodevelopmental alterations in a group of infants and children from the Netherlands. A similar potential association between immune system deficits in infants and increasing PCB, dioxin, and furan levels in human milk is a preliminary indication in an ongoing study of Canadian Inuit. Very little is known about the inter-generational effects associated with long-term exposure to these contaminants.” http://www.carc.org/pubs/v25no2/w252.htm

It looks like, for now, the recommendation is to still breastfeed as the benefits outweigh the risks. As was pointed out on several websites, there is no long-term studies that prove that infants are being harmed by the PCB’s and other compounds present in breast milk, but it is a topic that should be further studied.

Evaluate:
Thankfully the fifth section of this module contained some cultural relevance for us history teachers! Each week I am learning more about science that I did not know, or just forgot, but much of it does not apply to what I am teaching. However, the cultural connections are wonderful in each lesson and prompt me to think more about how our physical world affects the relationship we have with each other and our cultural identities.

One final link to the Conservation Science Institute that beautifully highlights the problems of Arctic contamination:
http://www.conservationinstitute.org/ocean_change/ocean_pollution/contaminantsinalaska.htm