Thursday, April 1, 2010

Two Blog Reviews

Explore Alaska! Stephanie Thornton



I found it enjoyable to read about Stephanie’s own experiences in her blog, particularly about her visit to Pompeii. I think travel is so important for teachers because it gives us a more well-rounded perspective of the places we teach about. I think it is easier to incorporate indigenous perspectives into our lessons if we have actually visited indigenous cultures personally as Stepanie has.

I think the blog was laid out professionally, and it was easy to read. I loved the beautiful photos that accompanied each blog entry, and would have enjoyed even more. It is clear that Stephanie is comfortable with the blog format and the layout stayed consistent throughout.

I also share an interest in Antarctica and would be interested in traveling there as well. As Stephanie pointed out, it is clear that global warming is happening and it would be great to see the South Pole before it changes too dramatically.

I liked how the final lesson included references to this class; I think a lot of the materials from this class are useful and valid for use in Alaska Studies classes or other history classes. I really liked the idea of the students creating their own Venn diagram comparing and contrasting the Western perspective and the Native perspective. The extensive list of sources for the students to use is also great. I think it will be a great lesson to teach.

In conclusion, a nice job overall and a pleasure to read!

Closing the Cultural Gap: Adriana Rodriguez



What I first noticed about this blog was the Emily Dickinson quote; I also love this poet, so I decided to pursue reading this blog.

I felt a connection to Adriana when she mentioned it is often difficult as a teacher to mesh the “connectedness” of everything together. As a history teacher we can use stories to connect one generation to the next, but I understand the difficulty in pulling everything together into a big picture for the students. I liked how Adriana pointed out that the oral stories of elders are wonderful histories, but it is sad that so few are actually written down.

This blog looked professional and had a soothing background. I thought the photos were wonderful and especially enjoyed the one of the polar bears. The only criticism I have of the blog was that they were not in any particular order and it was difficult to jump around to try to read them in order.

I liked that Adriana included her own cryosphere training in her blog; it gave a personal experience element to the science that she was discussing. It is obvious that she is a well-traveled and knowledgeable teacher. I would not mind being a student in her class!

1 comment:

  1. Great choices for review. I should say that Adriana joined the class half way in at my invitation, so her blogs were out of sequence because she had to catch up and keep up at the same time.

    ReplyDelete