Sunday, February 28, 2010

Module V Response

Essential Question: How are climate, cultures and oceans all connected?

Explain:
With 14% of Alaskan subsistence being marine mammals, the ocean is very tied to the culture of Alaska Natives. Walrus, beluga and bowhead whales, and harbor seals are a few of the creatures that Natives rely on for food and cultural significance.

Just this week, a story came across various news feeds that the village of Noorvik is celebrating because a 96-year ban on Native dancing has been lifted. According to the article, “motions and songs represent the movements of fishing, ice hopping, even traveling by snowmobile.” It is very special for this village to reestablish the connection between the ocean and their cultural expression of the ties they have to nature.

http://www.thestate.com/2010/02/21/1168070/native-dancing-ban-lifted-in-alaska.html



It will be interesting to see how climate change might impact Alaska Natives in the future. According to George Owletuck, thinning sea ice makes hunting more difficult, dangerous, and less productive. If our warming trend continues, Native communities will be forced to change their subsistence practices that have supported them for thousands of years.

Extend:
One of the interesting things about the decisions surrounding ocean resources in Alaska is that aboriginal knowledge is not always considered. An example of this would be the decisions surrounding the bowhead whale stock in the Bering Sea in the 1970’s. The IWC (International Whaling Commission) voted to ban the Eskimos' subsistence harvest of bowhead whales because they felt the stock had dropped down to 10% of that of previous years. If the IWC would have relied on the Eskimos' local verification and qualitative observations, they would have found that, in fact, there were about four times more whales that they thought based on Western research.



Fortunately, this story has a good ending; the AEWC (Alaska Eskimo Whaling Commission) was formed in 1977, and convinced the U.S. Government to use indigenous knowledge sources when predicting bowhead stocks.

The current goals of the AEWC demonstrate the connection betweens the ocean, culture, and climate for the Eskimo people. The goals are:
1.    Preserve and enhance a vital marine resource, the bowhead whale, including the protection of its habitat.
2.    To protect Eskimo subsistence bowhead whaling
3.    To protect and enhance the Eskimo culture, traditions, and activities associated with bowhead whales and
4.    To undertake research and educational activites related to bowhead whales.


Evaluate:
This week’s lesson was interesting, but most of the videos, labs, and resources are not something I would typically find helpful to teach U.S. or World History. However, it is undeniable that there is a strong connection between cultures and the environment, so that is what I focused on in my response. Having visited Kipnuk, Unalakleet, Nome, and other areas of Alaska, it is obvious that the ocean has a huge impact on the very existence of those who live there. Local feasts highlight the abundance of food that the oceans provide, and the local dances provide an artistic interpretation of that connection. Last, but not least, there is a sense of community that is developed when harvesting from nature that we do not usually see in Western, industrialized cultures.

1 comment:

  1. I really appreciate the way you take the science behind this course and apply it to your area of social studies. Great connections!

    ReplyDelete