How do stories of cataclysmic events inform students about geosciences and cultures?
Explain:
As a history teacher, I have found that students are most interested in stories. Facts, dates, and minutia are interesting to few, but if I can present those things in a story format, students generally respond positively and retain the information indefinitely. Cataclysmic events such as the recent earthquake in Haiti provide many stories that are interesting to students. Stories of human death, survival, altruism, crime, and pain grab students at their emotional cores. Once that interest is established, a teacher can bring in background information. Why do these kinds of events happen? What was the reason an earthquake specifically “targeted” Haiti?
Using stories as a stepping-stone, students can learn more about geosciences and the culture of the affected region. A science teacher could have students use the tools of Google Earth to find the tectonic plates of the region and find out why a particular event happened. As a history teacher, I would focus on the cultural aspects and look at how earthquakes have been coped with over time, and if there are different outlooks towards them between indigenous or Western peoples.
Finally, cataclysmic stories can launch a discussion about how to be prepared for future disastrous events. In researching for this blog entry, I came across dozens of websites that discussed how to improve early warning systems for earthquakes and tsunamis. Technology is constantly changing and I think students would find it particularly interesting since we live in a state that has frequent earthquakes and has the chance for future tsunamis.
Extend:
This unit prompted me to think back to September and an event that affected dozens of students in my school. The tsunami that hit the Samoan islands had a death toll that was miniscule in comparison to the recent Haiti tragedy, but it reached the Samoan population at East High in a very real way. Samoan families are very interconnected and they have many relatives that live in the Anchorage area (check out Julia O’Malley’s column http://community.adn.com/node/143817). I don’t believe there were any students at East that did not have a personal connection to this tragedy.
I was curious about how this particular tsunami was created. After some research, I found that it is part of the Tonga region where the Pacific and Australia plates converge. The Pacific plate subducts between the Australian plate. The September earthquake that caused the tsunami was considered a normal fault rupture. This region has a long history of major earthquakes; at least 13 others over 7.0 magnitude since 1900. The Google Earth image below show earthquakes in the last two days and also shows the volcanoes of the islands.
How did the Samoans deal with this cataclysmic event? News stories reported people scrambling for safety, but most were not able to deal with the wall of water that consumed the islands. http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/asiapcf/09/30/samoa.earthquake/index.html


The Samoan culture is interesting in that it has a long oral history. They have many legends that detail the creation of the islands http://www.nps.gov/npsa/historyculture/legendpo.htm and early Samoan life. I could not find any specific legends that dealt with earthquakes and volcanoes, but it was interesting to find in several sources that community-based education has been in place in the Samoan islands and has been credited with saving many lives compared with relying on ancestral stories. http://uscnews.usc.edu/global/planning_saved_lives_in_samoan_tsunami.htmln
In this particular case, it seems that the local culture has adopted modern technology as a life-saving asset. While the legends are still a part of local history, it is recognized that planning as a community and technological advancements can also play a role in saving their culture.
In conclusion, it is easy to make connections between culture, science, and our students. This is especially true when our students have a vested interest in their own cultures and their ancestral homes.
Evaluate:
This unit was my favorite so far. Earthquakes, tsunamis and other natural events can cause life-changing events here in our own state. It was fun to use Google Earth even further to look at different areas in Alaska to see where recent earthquakes have been happening and to see where the tectonic plates lie.


Wow! Compelling narrative. Great images and excellent links.
ReplyDelete